Ask around for the major health providors in Ohio. Find out who specializes in insurance, and then find out who specializes in what you are specifically looking for. For example, some health providors might specialize in small business group insurance and others may write more policies with larger businesses. If you are looking for individual insurance, you have to find out who's writing the most policies for individuals. This information varies by state, so I can't help you. Nor can many who do not live in Ohio. Your best best is to google "major health providors in Ohio" and start with that information. You don't have to sign up right away. You can shop between providors to find out who can help you. When you sign up again, ask a lot of questions. The best trick to health insurance is to be well educated in what you are covered for.